A 2008 settlement agreement that a lawyer for Prince Andrew said would protect him from allegations he sexually assaulted an American when she was 17 may remain under wraps, a New York judge said on Wednesday.
U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan made the ruling in a brief order issued a day after Andrew’s attorney requested that the document remain sealed when he files arguments as to why he thinks the judge should overturn the trial. Lawyer Andrew Brettler said he wanted to include a copy of the agreement with the arguments.
In the August trial, Virginia Giuffre claims the prince repeatedly assaulted her in 2001. Andrew said he never had sex with her.
Brettler, who called the lawsuit “without merit,” said neither the prince nor Giuffre was claiming the release deal should remain sealed, but they demanded that it be kept secret as it is subject to a court order. protection of another judge presiding over a federal civil action. At New York.
The settlement agreement was reached between Giuffre and Jeffrey Epstein, who was found dead aged 66 in his cell in 2019 pending a sex trafficking trial in a New York federal prison. His death was considered suicide.
In his order on Wednesday, Kaplan noted that Jeffrey Epstein’s estate also does not claim that the settlement agreement must remain sealed.
Kaplan appeared to urge the parties to ask the judge in the other case – Loretta A. Preska – to allow the document to be unsealed, saying Preska “may well consider a request … to allow public disclosure of the settlement. Agreement. “
“But that’s for her to say,” he wrote, ruling that the deal can be put under seal and stay that way unless Preska and Kaplan decide otherwise.
In his Tuesday filing, Brettler said the deal “frees Prince Andrew and others from any alleged liability arising from claims Ms Giuffre has made against Prince Andrew here”.
A hearing in Prince Andrew’s trial is scheduled for next week.