Newcomer AJ Bunker got to pick the first of all the boys, and after that all the boys picked a girl, meaning Sharon Gaffka was dumped.
AJ chose Hugo Hammond, who was in a friendship with Hugo, which means it was Sharon’s turn to pack his bags.
But viewers wondered why AJ chose the boys, given that she had failed to properly connect with anyone beyond a chat and a little flirtation.
Hugo said he wanted to give AJ a chance, but fans are convinced he doesn’t like AJ.
Get the news you want straight to your inbox. Sign up for the Mirror newsletter here.
One of them tweeted, “I find it a little unfair that AJ could choose when it was the boys’ choice. If she returns home without ever being in a relationship, too bad. This is what happened to Chuggs ”.
“I firmly believe that if AJ had not obtained the first choice, Hugo would have chosen Sharon as a friendly couple #loveIsland, added another.
“AJ is lucky to have been the first to choose, otherwise she won’t even have had time to unpack before being sent home,” commented a third.
“Aj after I tried to crack up with everyone, then told Hugo you were my first choice… no one else wanted her,” added a fourth.
After AJ made his choice, it was the boys’ turn to choose the girl they wanted to date, starting with the bombshell Danny Bibby.
Danny had flirted with Lucinda Strafford, Kaz Kamwi and Sharon, the latter being in a relationship with Hugo.
He said: “I would like to choose this girl because I am attracted to her, she is beautiful and I see myself having a future with her.
So the girl I would like to be in a relationship with is Lucinda, ”he confirmed.
Aaron then confirmed that he was dating “his sister in the villa” but hinted that he would have chosen Lucinda if he had had the chance.
“The girl I would like to be in a relationship with is Kaz,” he confirmed.
Jake Cornish then teamed up with Liberty Poole, which came as no surprise as Liberty recently revealed that she is falling in love.
Liam then chose Millie, and Faye was chosen by new boy Teddy, who said they were “getting stronger and stronger”.
Chloe was chosen by Toby, despite their somewhat hectic week as Toby reacted badly to discovering that they were chosen the least compatible.
Sharon burst into tears as she was the last girl left standing, and her fellow islanders ran and hugged her.
* Love Island continues tomorrow night on ITV2 at 9 p.m.