Media reaction Wales v Scotland: “Pitiful, directionless, lost – from Gatland the Great Redeemer to Pivac the restless beginner


Wales’ 14-10 loss to Scotland in the Six Nations final marked a fifth trotting loss and the end of an unforgettable championship campaign where they won only against Italy.Pressure is mounting on Wales boss Wayne Pivac as he attempts to evolve his squad into a different style of play than his predecessor Warren Gatland.

But Wales need a clear win, with a four-game Autumn Nations Cup kicking off in less than a fortnight.

Here’s a look at what the England-based media are saying about the collapse of Wales, from the Grand Slam Championship one year to fifth place this year…

Steve James, Sunday Times

It was a shocking game to watch, especially so soon after the previous Bledisloe Cup match, but an even more shocking result for Wales.

They, and especially their head coach, Wayne Pivac, needed the win, even if it was ugly. As it stands, the loss dooms them, with only the lone victory over Italy, to their worst Six Nations campaign since 2007. And needless to say, that was before Warren Gatland took the lead. relay.

Wales under Pivac are not looking to beat anyone, but are learning the hard way that international rugby demands physical battles be won before anything else can be accomplished.

Wales look a bit lost at the moment, a bit unsure of how they should play. Pivac tries to re-educate a group of players who have been rooted with a certain method.

The times have changed. Pivac needs time, but it will also need results to wait for this moment.

Mick Cleary, telegraph

It would be hard to sweeten this performance from Wales

Wales were flat and confused, unable to break free or overpower their opponents who won for the first time in Wales in 18 years. Wales lacked confidence and direction as they slumped towards their fifth straight loss, a pitiful state for a side that were reigning Grand Slam champions.

There will be alarm bells as Wayne Pivac grapples with his undernourished team and the growing demand for improvement. Wales were well and truly led during the blackout, giving up 11 penalties in that phase alone. From Gatland the Great Redeemer to the newcomer Pivac, overseeing Wales’ worst campaign in three years, only the second time in 13 years, they have finished in such a modest position.

Alun Wyn Jones should have been a miracle worker to turn this West Walian water into wine. Just 12 months ago, Wales were on the verge of beating South Africa to advance to the World Cup final. It is an alarming fall from grace.

Paul Rees, Guardian

The joy of Scotland was the desperation of Wales on an unreal afternoon in Llanelli as the lack of crowds was telling. The team that won the Grand Slam last season desperately lacked the energy of home support as they found themselves overwhelmed in most areas, especially distribution, by the men in blue, who celebrated a first win in Wales since 2002.

Wales spent the game looking for a place but never found it.

There was a marked improvement in defense where their line across the field rarely allowed Scotland to sniff out the winning line let alone gallop over it, but they offered little in attack and were unable to win in the last 10 minutes when the Scots healed one-point ahead.

Richard Bath, telegraph

Pity poor Alun Wyn Jones. A goliath of the game he perhaps is, and it may have been a record-breaking match for the Welsh Lock, whose 149th appearance surpassed the record set by Richie McCaw, but even such a historic footnote wasn’t enough to save a struggling match either. through difficult conditions or to resuscitate Welsh fortunes.

If the Wales talisman was disappointed with how this heavy and nervous match in an empty Parc y Scarlets went, those emotions will be reflected in every corner of his home country. Wales continue to defend as if Shaun Edwards were at the helm, but they offered little attack let alone up front.

For a besieged Wayne Pivac, who has tried to change Wales’ playstyle using his predecessor’s squad but with a hard core of veterans hoping for a final Lions tour, these are the times dark. Finishing fifth in the Six Nations was not part of his mission, and with a break-up clause next year, he must feel the heat.


Wales ended their first Six Nations campaign under Wayne Pivac with a historic loss to Scotland at Llanelli, the first at home to the Scots in 18 years to end an unforgettable tournament.

The final score of 14-10 put more misery on Pivac’s men, their fifth straight loss since defeating Italy in their Six Nations opener. Welsh fans struggled to see a coherent game plan under Pivac, with many claiming the team had no direction. It was quick to call it one of Wales’ worst performances in recent memory.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here