Why does Rand Paul think he knows better than Anthony Fauci?


The Republican senator from Kentucky was there again on Wednesday, using an audition on Capitol Hill to travel again to Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and a member of the White House Coronavirus Task Force .

Paul: “Do you have any doubts about your mitigation recommendations given the evidence that despite everything we’ve done in the US, our death rate is essentially worse than Sweden’s, which equates to the world’s less developed who is unable to do Do you have any doubts? Are you ready to look at the data that countries that have done very little actually have a lower death rate than the United States? ”

Fauci: “You know, senator, I would be happy at another time to sit down and go over the details. You said a lot of different things. … Compare Sweden’s death rate with that of other comparable Scandinavian countries. It’s worse. . ”

According to data from Johns Hopkins University, Sweden’s death rate from Covid-19 is around 57 people per 100,000. Norway, which borders Sweden, has a death rate of five people per 100,000. . Finland? Just over six people per 100,000.

So Paul is wrong and Fauci is right. But that did not stop the senator!

“You’ve been a huge fan of Cuomo and the closure of New York,” he told Fauci. “You congratulated New York on its policies. New York had the highest death rate in the world. ”

Paul also suggested that New York City had achieved some sort of “community immunity” because so many people were infected with the virus, as to why its current number of cases and death rate were so low – not the ones. Mitigation tactics offered by Facui such as the mask – wear and tear, social distancing and hand washing.

“I dispute that,” Fauci replied, adding, “It happens all the time with Senator Rand. You’re not listening to what the CDC director said. … If you think 22% is collective immunity, I believe you are alone in this. ”

Again, Paul is wrong and Fauci is right.

In early May, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo announced that 21% of people tested the previous week in New York City had shown Covid-19 antibodies in their system, a finding suggesting many more people had been exposed – and had immune reactions. – as the hospitalization and mortality rates show.

But even the most optimistic view of collective immunity is that 60% of the public would need to have anti-Covid antibodies for the disease to stop its spread without proper mitigation efforts. Neither New York nor the rest of the country comes close to that number.

Regardless of his swings and hiccups on Wednesday, if the past is a prologue, Paul will continue after Fauci.

During a congressional hearing in May, Paul openly questioned Fauci’s expertise in decisions about reopening state economies.

“I think we should have a little humility in our belief that we know what’s best for the economy, and while I respect you, Dr Fauci, I don’t think you are the end,” said Paul. “I don’t think you’re the only person making the decision. We can listen to your advice, but there are people on the other side who are saying there will be no push and then we can safely open the economy. . And the facts will confirm it. ”

Uh. …

Then there was this of a Senate hearing in July. “Dr. Fauci, every day we seem to hear things from you that we can’t do,” Paul said. “It is important to understand that if society obediently submits to an expert and the expert is wrong, there can be a lot of harm. Take, for example, government experts who continue to call for schools and daycares to remain closed or who recommend restrictions. that prevent a school from functioning. ”

CNN has verified this claim by Paul and, it will stun you, he is not right.

And let’s not forget that Paul, who had Covid-19 himself, cast his skepticism about the need for the public to get the possible vaccine against the virus.

“I’m kind of pro-vaccine, but also pro-freedom,” Paul said in mid-July. “Look, there are millions of us like me now who are immune. Will they hold me back and put a needle in my arm? They probably will, because these people believe in the idea that they are so right and their cause is so right that they can inflict it on others. ”

Did I mention that Paul is a doctor? And so should have a higher bar to output data that is misleading at best?

So here is. This is where we are in the sixth month of our fight against the coronavirus. Which is quite depressing.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here