How Italy is coping better as Spain, France and UK face second wave Covid nightmares


Students wearing face masks and keeping their social distance arrive at Newton Scientific High during class after pandemic closure in Rome, Italy Antonio Masiello | Getty Images via Bloomberg

Text size:

istaly was a symbol of the first wave of the pandemic. It was the first country in the world to enter a nationwide lockdown, as its hospitals – especially in cities like Bergamo and Cremona in the north – struggled to cope with the surge in cases and there was a sharp increase deaths.

As fear of a second wave grips Europe, Italy seems to be coping much better than other countries like France, Spain and the UK. This is hardly the time for complacency; as Britain can attest, this virus may come back with a vengeance. But in the past two weeks, Italy has recorded just under 35 cases per 100,000 population – compared to almost 315 in Spain, nearly 200 in France and 76.5 in the UK The average number of deaths has amounted to 0.3 per 100,000 inhabitants, or a third of the French rate and almost a tenth of Spain. Italy’s numbers are only slightly worse than Germany’s, which has been hailed as a model of good pandemic management.

Italy has so far been able to avoid the kind of new restrictions put in place in other parts of Europe. The UK has announced that restaurants and pubs will close at 10 p.m. and there will be fines of 200 pounds ($ 254) for those who do not wear masks as required. In France, Paris has imposed the same 10 p.m. curfew in bars and restaurants and closed gyms. In Italy, social life continues unhindered – even though the government has forced nightclubs to close again after a series of new cases of Covid in the summer, particularly on the island of Sardinia.

Read also: For the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, the recovery of Covid takes the shape of a “W”

So what works in the Italian approach? It is difficult to determine exactly which factors improve a country’s ability to control an epidemic. In the spring it emerged that the early introduction of a strict lockdown – as Greece did – was a recipe for less pain. And yet the recent sharp drop in cases in Sweden, after the country avoided a lockdown and other draconian measures taken elsewhere, has raised doubts about what exactly is effective. The Italian government does not appear to have taken any drastically different measures from the rest of the continent.

Two things may help explain Italy’s relatively strong performance – so far – in preventing a second wave of the virus. The first is the effectiveness of its tracking and traceability system in identifying and isolating contacts from those who test positive. Italy tests around 100,000 people per day, which is not high by European standards. But only around 2% of these tests are positive, which is low compared to elsewhere in Europe.

This slower spread than elsewhere can also be explained by the second factor: Italians seem rather good at wearing masks and maintaining their social distance. Doctors are also convinced that they have become better at treating Covid-19 – although that only explains the low death rate, not the limited number of cases.

Yet none of these explanations are perfect and it’s important not to get carried away by Italy’s apparent resilience. The country’s healthcare system has traditionally ranked well in international comparisons, but it failed to contain the first phase of the pandemic, possibly because it was caught off guard.

There is also evidence that Italians have largely complied with the requirement to wear masks in the spring, and yet it was weeks before the number of deaths and cases declined. It is quite possible that Italy will experience a second wave delayed compared to France and Spain. The UK suffered its first outbreak much later than Italy or Spain, but ended up with an equally high human cost.

Rome should therefore remain on the alert. It only takes a few missteps for the epidemic to spiral out of control. For now, however, Italian citizens can be proud of their health care system and of themselves. Bloomberg

Read also: These countries think their government has done a good job in the face of the Covid pandemic

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube and Telegram

Why the news media is in crisis and how to fix it

You are reading this because you value quality, intelligent and objective journalism. Thank you for your time and trust.

You also know that the media is facing an unprecedented crisis. You are also likely to hear about the brutal layoffs and pay cuts plaguing the industry. There are many reasons why the media economy is broken. But the big problem is that the right people still don’t pay enough for good journalism.

We have a newsroom full of talented young reporters. We also have the strongest editing and fact-checking team in the country, top press photographers and video professionals. We are building India’s most ambitious and energetic information platform. And I just turned three.

At ThePrint, we invest in quality journalists. We pay them fairly. As you may have noticed, we don’t mind spending whatever it takes to ensure our reporters get to where the story is.

This comes at a considerable cost. In order for us to continue to provide quality journalism, we need readers like you to pay.
If you think we deserve your support, join us in this effort to strengthen fair, free, courageous and questioning journalism. Please click on the link below. Your support will define ThePrint’s future.

Support our journalism