France’s highest court dismisses base of online law targeting hate speech –


France’s highest court has rejected most of a bill that would have forced giants such as Facebook and Twitter’s social media to remove all heinous content within 24 hours, it said Thursday (June 18).The decision rendered by the Constitutional Council, which declared the law too interferes with free speech, is a setback for President Emmanuel Macron. He vowed to make France a leader by limiting the dissemination of illegal content and false information on the most used of platforms.

The bill was approved by France’s lower house last July, but was yet to be approved by the Constitional Council.

Under the bill, social media groups have faced fines of up to 4% of their worldwide income for not having to remove in a day “manifestly illegal” content related to the race, sex, religion, sexual orientation or disability.

Several free speech advocacy groups had argued that the bill could pave the way for state censorship because it does not clearly define illegal content.

“(These measures) undermine the exercise of freedom of expression and communication in a manner that is unnecessary, inappropriate and disproportionate,” the court said.

The court, which is the French equivalent of the US Supreme Court, cited 1789 “Declaration of Human and Citizen Rights” which is the preamble to the constitution.

He noted that the bill provides that the administration would have had the lead role in their decision on the illegal content, without the intervention of a judge.

This could push corporate social media to remove more online content than necessary for fear of punishment, he said. The court also said that the 24 hour window time was “particularly brief”.

The court also slapped another provision of the bill, under which any content considered to be child pornography, or terrorists in the wild, should have been removed within an hour.

Facebook and Twitter did not immediately respond to requests for comment.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here