Daniel Radcliffe, the star of the Harry Potter franchise, replied on Monday to the creator of the JK franchise Rowling’s controversial gender identity tweets, directly addressing fans who may have felt pain while reading the comments by the author, which some describe as transphobic.
Rowling, who has often been criticized by the big fandom Potter for his publications on social networks, triggered a backlash over the weekend after having ridiculed a headline on “people who have their periods”.
“Gens Menstruating people.’ I’m sure there was a word for these people, “she tweeted on saturday. “Someone is helping me. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud? ”
Shortly after, the author’s name was in vogue on Twitter, with many accusing him of transphobia – of which she was previously charged.
“Hi @jk_rowling, using non-gendered language means going beyond the idea that woman = womb”, Clue, a rule-following app responded. “Feminists used to be mocked for wanting to change sexist language, but it’s now common to say firefighter instead of firefighter. ”
“What JK Rowling says is harmful and dangerous and trans and non-binary witches and wizards deserve to be welcomed and loved in the shit of the Harry Potter community !!!! ” wrote actress Tessa Netting.
Radcliffe, who has no public presence on social media, wrote a sincere response to Rowling’s comments in a blog article for The Trevor Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to preventing suicide among LGBTQ + youth. .
“Transgender women are women,” he writes. “Any statement to the contrary erases the identity and dignity of transgender people and goes against all the advice given by professional health associations that have much more expertise in this area than Jo (Rowling) or me. ”
Rowling did not apologize. Although following on from her tweet on Saturday, she wrote in quotation marks words that she had been called in as part of the reaction, including “witch” and “TERF,” which means radical transexclusive feminist.
” The times are changing. Hatred of women is eternal, “she says. wrote.
She followed this tweet with a three-part tweet thread in which she defended her previous comments.
“If the sex is not real, there is no attraction for the same sex,” she says. tweeted. “If sex is not real, the lived reality of women around the world is erased. I know and love trans people, but the erasure of the concept of sex takes away from many the opportunity to discuss their lives in a meaningful way. It’s not hatred to tell the truth. ”
“The idea that women like me, who have been empathetic towards trans people for decades, feel related because they are vulnerable in the same way as women – that is, to violence masculine – “hate” trans people because they think sex is real and has had consequences – is nonsense, “she said. second tweet.
“I respect the right of every trans person to live in an authentic and comfortable way,” she said. added. “I would walk with you if you were discriminated against because of your trans. At the same time, my life has been shaped by being a woman. I don’t think it’s odious to say it.
A Rowling representative did not immediately respond to CNN’s request for comment regarding Radcliffe’s position and the outrage surrounding his tweet.“Clearly we need to do more”
Radcliffe began his article by asserting that his comments are not “in conflict” between him and Rowling, which he wrote “undoubtedly responsible for the course my life has taken”.
“According to The Trevor Project, 78% of transgender and non-binary youth reported being discriminated against because of their gender identity,” wrote Radcliffe, who said he was “honored to work with” The Trevor Project over the past decade. “It is clear that we must do more to support transgender and non-binary people, not to invalidate their identity and not to cause further harm. ”
He then referred readers to the Trevor Project Guide to be an ally of transgender and non-binary youth, noting that he “always learns to be a better ally.”
The 30-year-old actor then spoke specifically to fans of the wizarding world, or “everyone who now feels that their experience with books has been tarnished or diminished.”
“I am deeply sorry for the pain these comments have caused you,” he wrote. “I really hope you don’t lose all that was precious to you in these stories. If these books have taught you that love is the most powerful force in the universe, capable of overcoming anything; if they have taught you that strength is in diversity, and that dogmatic ideas of purity lead to the oppression of vulnerable groups; if you believe that a particular character is trans, not binary or gender fluid, or that he is gay or bisexual; if you found something in these stories that resonated with you and helped you at any point in your life – then it’s between you and the book you’re reading, and it’s sacred. ”
Radcliffe is not the only celebrity to have expressed his views on Rowling’s tweet.
Katie Leung, who played the character of Potter Chang Chang, tweeted: “So you want my thoughts on Cho Chang? Okay, so here it’s… (thread), ”then linked to a series of fundraisers for organizations working to promote the safety of trans people.
Jonathan Van Ness of Netflix’s Queer Eye also responded to the author.
“Trans women are women”, Van Ness wrote, a link to Rowling’s tweet. “Blacks and trans non-blacks face discrimination every day. They die. We fight for blacks and trans people and you do that? “
History of controversial articles
Rowling has 14.5 million Twitter followers, and his “Harry Potter” franchise was celebrated for its acceptance messages. However, over the years, fans have expressed disappointment with the author for his social media posts which sometimes project the opposite message.
In 2018, she was criticized for having liked a tweet from a user that referred to “men in dresses”. A Rowling spokesperson at the time told Newsweek that “it was a mistake.” “I’m afraid J.K. Rowling had an awkward, middle-aged moment, and it’s not the first time that she has favored holding her phone incorrectly! The representative said to the publication.
In December Rowling disappointed the Harry Potter community after expressing support for Maya Forstater, a woman who lost a labor court after comments she made on social media about transgender people.
Forstater has filed a complaint against the Center for Global Development and CGD Europe, an international development think tank, after losing his job as a researcher following comments on Twitter criticizing the British government’s plans to allow people to self-identify their gender. In a report posted on Twitter, Forstater said she believes “sex is a biological fact and is immutable. ”
Rowling announced support for Forstater on Twitter writes: “Dress as you see fit. Call yourself whatever you want. Sleep with any consenting adult who has you. Live your best life in peace and security. But to force women to quit their jobs to declare that sex is real? #IStandWithMaya # ThisIsNotADrill. ”
The comments shocked the fans. “As a devoted Harry Potter fan who is also transgender, it was like a punch in the stomach,” wrote author Jackson Bird in an editorial for The New York Times in December 2019. “Through his books, Mrs. Rowling helped teach a generation the power not only of tolerance, but of fierce acceptance and unconditional love. ”
GLAAD, a non-profit organization dedicated to LGBTQ + issues, cited Bird’s column in its response to Rowling’s tweet this weekend.
“JK Rowling continues to align itself with an ideology that deliberately distorts the facts about gender identity and trans people,” the organization said. wrote. “In 2020, there is no excuse to target trans people. ”
“We are with young trans people, especially Harry Potter fans hurt by his inaccurate and cruel tweets,” Addition of GLAAD.